21; so much to turn over
November 20, 2009
As the story goes on, Birdie becomes more and more paranoid and anxious that she and her mother have been found out. As she becomes more tense and aware, her mother takes on a more lackadaisical attitude that makes me think she was lying all along. That it was something she made up. Like it was a game to her, and now she has found Jim and she is in love and Bernadette was right. If she really was in trouble- that dumb woman for putting all of herself in a man, letting her daughter disappear to Mona’s for days at a time not asking who what when where why (227)– she would be more cautious or a little more concerned about things. And OK, Jim isn’t a fed, but I still think Sandy should have discussed letting Jim in on the secret with Birdie before telling him. I guess it was hard to talk to her, considering Birdie said she essentially wanted nothing to do with them and avoided them.
Furthermore, the fact that her mother hid Dot’s note etc. It makes me feel like Birdie was almost kidnapped by her own mother. It’s sad when Birdie sits there thinking that she was the unwanted one. She was the one who neither her mother nor father fought for. Sandy is now so absorbed in her own life- and good for her; she should have a life of her own, but she doesn’t even notice things that were crucial to her before, i.e. when Birdie takes off her Star of David necklace.
I feel badly for Jim, making such an effort and Birdie being such a B about it. She is still young, though. Reading over her lines about how, on 256, she says, “But you don’t understand. You can’t be my dad. I already have a dad. And he was a whole hell of a lot cooler than you. Besides, we were doing just find without you.” Ok Birdie, aren’t you the one who said your dad paid all of his attention to Cole, and ignored you when you were around? Your dad may have been interesting, but didn’t you say he made you feel shitty most of the time?
This section contained good words, like chintzy and sordid and tumultuous.
It was abrupt, the way that Senna decided to shift the story and have Birdie run away. It was as if she handed the story to someone else and said, you make the decision for me; what should happen next? I did not see it coming at all. There wasn’t much of a build up to it. Was there? Did I miss it? There are so many possibilites as to what will happen next. Who will she find? What if Dot is not at the address on the post card. What if she is? What will it BE like?!
November 20, 2009 at 2:14 am
Courtney–
First I just want to say that I love your blogs! When I read them I can picture how u would say every last word! hahaha! I like what you said about Sandy being immersed in her own life (not noticing Birdie’s missing Star David. Honestly, Sandy is not the best mother and really not the best model for her to be leaving impressions on Birdie. Does Sandy notice what she is doing to Birdie? Sandy talks about damage control but how is she going to control the damage she has done to Birdie? Something to think about! Great post girl!
November 24, 2009 at 9:04 pm
haha thanks! yeah I don’t know how Sandy doesn’t realize what she is doing and the mark she is leaving on her daughter..
November 20, 2009 at 2:15 am
I definately did not think that Birdie would run away either. I know that she didn’t really like being there, but I didn’t think she would pack up and leave. Maybe she’ll go to NYC…she loved being with the dancers on the sidewalk lol.
November 24, 2009 at 9:05 pm
I am really sorry I just have to tell you it’s definitely with two i’s.
But yeah she really did like those dancers! hah, she now never wants to be with her family.. she is really desperate to identify as “black” again.
November 20, 2009 at 3:38 am
I feel so bad for Birdie. She is so young to have to go through all this, and now this new Jim guy wants to take on her father role? I think he needs to step back and not be so forward with her and give Birdie time to adjust.
November 22, 2009 at 9:49 pm
I also felt bad for Jim. I wrote about the change of view i had of Jim. He was desperately trying to be accepted by B but not matter what he did, it was never enough and he was always denied by B. In regards to B running away i guess for me i expected it. I think the event that gave me that feeling was when B feels betrayed by her mother for telling Jim the truth. I think she felt like she could no longer trust her own mother and therefore needed to get away.
November 22, 2009 at 11:15 pm
I disagree about Jim, I still don’t like him. I think that anyone dating a person with children needs to tread extra carefully, and Jim just dove right in as if he were the savior these women needed. It reminded me of when my Mom married my Step-Dad when I was a little girl. I think the nastiness is natural. As a child, you want to know that no matter how nasty you are to this new person that wants to be in your life, that they will still be there. I think that is what Birdie was doing to Jim. It took me years and years to accept my step-father as a Dad, and I would expect it to take even longer for Birdie, simply because Sandy has trained her to never trust anyone from a ridiculously young age.
November 24, 2009 at 9:06 pm
I really like the way you put that. I’ve never been in that situation but I can definitely see your point and where you are coming from. Good call!!
November 24, 2009 at 12:42 pm
I loved the scene where Birdie takes off her necklace. This book is weird in the sense that no matter what ethnicity the characters choose to “pass” into, they are discriminated. Birdie becomes Jewish, and has pennies thrown at her (246).